[ < Back to quizzes ]

Which Gun Should I Buy?

The right first gun depends on four things: what the gun is for, how much you have shot, what you can spend, and how much recoil you can practice with comfortably. This quiz asks exactly those questions and matches you against real, in-production firearms using the same capability data that powers our builder. You get one clear recommendation, two alternates, and links to buy, accessorize, and read the full first gun buying guide.

Find your first gun in five questions

Answer in plain language. We score real, in-production firearms from our catalog against your goal, experience, budget, and comfort level, then hand you one clear pick with two backups.

Takes about a minute. No firearms knowledge required.

How the quiz picks your gun

Every recommendation is a real firearm from our catalog, never a hypothetical. Each platform carries 0-10 capability scores for close quarters, reliability, carry mobility, and distance work, plus its intended use cases and current price. Your answers set which of those axes matter and how hard: a home-defense answer weights close-quarters and reliability scores, a carry answer weights size and weight, budget caps the price, and the experience and recoil questions steer first-timers toward soft-shooting, simple-to-run platforms. The top score becomes your primary pick and the next two become alternates worth handling at a rental counter before you decide.

The quiz covers buying decisions, not skills. Once you own the gun, build fundamentals with our drill library and test what you know with the firearms knowledge quiz. Not sure a quiz is enough? The long-form breakdowns in Best First Gun for Beginners and Best Handgun for Women cover the same ground pick by pick.

Frequently Asked Questions

▶What gun should I buy first?
For most first-time buyers, a compact 9mm pistol like the Glock 19 Gen5 ($647) is the default answer: it covers home defense, concealed carry, and range training with one purchase, and it has the largest holster and accessory ecosystem of any handgun. If your only goal is learning to shoot, start cheaper and softer with a .22 LR like the Ruger 10/22 carbine ($359) or Taurus TX22 pistol ($322). If the gun will only ever guard your home, a shotgun like the Mossberg Maverick 88 Security ($290) or a 9mm carbine like the Ruger PC Carbine are easier to shoot well under stress than any pistol. The quiz on this page weighs those tradeoffs against your answers and names one pick.
▶Should my first gun be a pistol, rifle, or shotgun?
Pick a pistol if you want to carry it or want one gun that does everything; pick a rifle or shotgun if it will live at home. Pistols are the hardest category to shoot accurately, which is why new shooters who never plan to carry are usually better served by a long gun. A 9mm carbine such as the Ruger PC Carbine has roughly half the felt recoil of a 5.56 AR-15 and is far more forgiving than a pistol at home-defense distances, while a 12 gauge shotgun offers the most effect per shot at the cost of noticeably more recoil.
▶How much should I spend on a first gun?
Plan on $300 to $700 for the gun, then reserve $300 to $500 more for ammunition, eye and ear protection, secure storage, and at least one lesson in your first year. Reliable first guns exist at the bottom of that range: the Mossberg Maverick 88 Security is $290 and the Taurus TX22 is $322. The $500 to $900 band buys the most proven do-everything pistols, including the Glock 19 Gen5 and SIG P365. Spending more than $1,000 on a first gun only makes sense for a dedicated competition pistol or a duty-grade rifle or shotgun.
▶Is a .22 a good first gun?
Yes, a .22 LR is the best pure learning gun you can buy. Ammunition costs a fraction of 9mm, and the near-zero recoil lets you build grip, sight picture, and trigger control without developing a flinch. The Ruger 10/22 carbine ($359) and the S&W M&P 15-22 Sport are the standard first rifles, and the Ruger Mark IV 22/45 Tactical ($669) is the classic first pistol trainer. The tradeoff: .22 LR is not a defensive caliber, so if the same gun must protect your home, step up to a 9mm or a shotgun.
▶Should I rent a gun before buying it?
Yes. Rent or borrow your top pick before you buy whenever possible. Grip fit, recoil feel, and sight picture vary between shooters, and an hour with a rental costs $20 to $40 against a $500-plus purchase you might regret. Take our quiz result to a range with a rental counter, shoot 50 rounds through the primary pick and one alternate, and buy the one you shot better. Most indoor ranges stock the common recommendations: Glock 19, SIG P365, Shield Plus, and a 10/22 are on nearly every rental wall.
▶What is the easiest gun for a new shooter to handle?
The easiest defensive pistols to operate are the S&W M&P 380 Shield EZ ($399) and 9mm Shield EZ, designed around light slide-racking effort and soft recoil, followed by the Ruger Security-380. The easiest guns to shoot accurately are .22 LR trainers like the Ruger 10/22 and Taurus TX22. Among long guns, a 9mm carbine is the softest defensive option; 12 gauge pump shotguns are effective but have the sharpest recoil of common home-defense choices, so recoil-averse shooters should favor a gas-operated semi-auto like the Beretta A300 Ultima Patrol or the smaller-bore options.