Best Overall: Nightforce ATACR 1-8x ($2,900-$3,100) - Hell-and-back optic with exceptional ED glass, true 1x red dot brightness, bombproof durability. If you can afford it, this is the answer.
Best Performance Value: Primary Arms PLxC 1-8x RDB ($1,750-$2,000) - ATACR-level glass quality with RDB diffractive reticle technology. Lightweight, excellent eyebox, premium Japanese glass. Top pick for serious shooters.
Best Eyebox: Vortex Razor HD Gen II 1-6x ($1,400-$1,500) - Industry-leading ultra-forgiving eyebox, fast as a red dot at 1x. Still better than Gen III for eyebox performance.
Best Budget: SIG Tango MSR 1-6x ($400-$600) - Includes mount and flip caps, true 1x, 11 illumination levels. Best value under $600.