Best Overall: Sig Romeo 4T Pro ($570-$620) - Quad reticle, top controls, 50K hour battery, IPX-8 waterproof. The most feature-rich duty-grade red dot available.
Best Legendary Reliability: Aimpoint Micro T2 ($760-$920) - 5+ year battery, submersible to 80 feet, military-proven. The gold standard.
Best Innovation: Sig Romeo 8T AMR ($700-$800) - Auto-switching reticle when magnifier engages. Game-changing tech.
Best Budget: Holosun ARO ($110-$135) - Shake Awake, 50K battery, incredible value. Budget king.
Note: EOTech EXPS3 has delamination issues and isn't recommended for duty use. Trijicon MRO had quality issues (MRO HD theoretically fixed them, but Holosun offers better value). Just buy Holosun.